+86 21 63858668 +86 15201864468
[Party Building Leadership]     [Professional & High-Quality] [ International Competence]   [ Academic Highland]

The court adopted the defense's viewpoint and found the defendant guilty of intentional homicide, sentencing him lightly

Issuing time:2026-07-08 09:56Author:Shanghai Li Xiaohua Law Firm

By Lixiaohua lawyer, Shanghai Lixiaohua Lawfirm


Case Brief

Defendant A and the victim (male, 62 years old) have accumulated grievances due to neighborhood conflicts and have engaged in physical altercations. A rushed forward with a sharp knife and fiercely stabbed the victim's head, chest, and other critical areas. The victim fell to the ground and couldn't get up after being stabbed, and later died despite rescue efforts.


Defendant A was arrested by the police officers who arrived later to receive the report. After the incident was identified, the victim suffered injuries to the upper lobe of the left lung, resulting in massive blood loss and death.



Shanghai Li Xiaohua Law Firm is represented by senior Chinese criminal defense lawyer Li Xiaohua as the defense counsel for defendant A's intentional homicide case during the trial stage.


微信图片_20260708100541_58_47.jpg

Controversy Focus:

1. Can defendant A be deemed to have surrendered?

2. Can defendant A receive lenient punishment?


Lawyer's defense

During the trial, after the prosecutor presented the prosecution's viewpoint, the lawyer appointed by the victim's close relatives as the litigation representative believed that the defendant constituted the crime of intentional homicide and should bear full criminal responsibility.

Defense lawyer Li Xiaohua has no objection to the prosecution's accusation that A is guilty of intentional homicide and presents the following defense arguments:


1.The behavior of defendant A was caused by a neighborhood dispute, and defendant A who committed murder due to the intensification of the neighborhood dispute should be given lenient punishment according to law.

2.Defendant A is a person with limited criminal liability. The victim's legal representative proposes that defendant A is guilty of intentional homicide and should bear full criminal responsibility. The defense counsel believes that according to Article 18 of the Criminal Law of China, defendant A is a person with limited criminal liability and can be given a lighter or mitigated punishment in accordance with the law.

3.Defendant A was aware that someone else had reported the case and was still waiting for the police to arrive. During the arrest, he did not escape or resist arrest. After being arrested, he truthfully confessed all of his crimes and did not retract his confession.


According to the Opinions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Specific Issues Concerning Handling Surrender and Meritorious Deeds (2), those who knowingly wait at the scene while waiting for someone to report a crime, have no refusal to arrest at the time of arrest, and confess to the facts of the crime; According to Article 67 of the Criminal Law of our country, defendant A shall be deemed to have surrendered and may be given a lighter or mitigated punishment in accordance with the law.


laws and regulations

Article 22 of the "Several Opinions of the Supreme People's Court on Implementing the Criminal Policy of Balancing Leniency and Strictness" stipulates that "for crimes caused by the intensification of civil conflicts such as love, marriage, family, and neighborhood disputes, crimes caused by labor disputes, improper management, and other reasons, and whose criminal motives do not belong to evil or bad, and sudden crimes caused by the fault of the victim or based on righteous indignation or defensive factors, lenient punishment should be imposed as appropriate.


court judgment

The court fully listened to the opinions of both the prosecution and the defense, as well as the victim's legal representative. After deliberation by the Chamber of Deputies, it is deemed that:

Defendant A stabbed the victim's head, face, and chest with a knife, causing the victim's death. A's behavior constitutes intentional homicide. According to judicial appraisal, A is a person with limited criminal liability and can be given a lighter punishment according to law. Therefore, the opinion that A should bear full criminal responsibility as the litigation agent is not adopted.


The defense counsel's suggestion of lenient punishment based on this shall be adopted. The defense counsel's suggestion that A had surrendered and suggested a lighter punishment should be adopted.


The verdict is as follows:

1.Defendant A is guilty of intentional homicide and sentenced to life imprisonment with deprivation of political rights for life.

2.The tools used in the crime shall be confiscated.


Compliance Points

Li Xiaohua Law Firm collaborates with high-tech companies to develop legal service compliance products:

Deep integration of blockchain certificate storage and artificial intelligence reimbursement review technology

Realize the full process compliance management of "pre warning, in-process supervision, and post rectification".



Professional field:

Proficient in the field of commercial crime and foreign-related legal services and compliance, serving as a legal advisor


上海李小华律师事务所执业许可证号:23101200430089539


统一社会信用代码:313100007626418086


核验方式:登录全国律师执业诚信信息公示平台(credit.acla.org.cn),输入统一社会信用代码查询

Shanghai Li Xiaohua Law Firm Practice License Number: 23101200430089539


Unified Social Credit Code:313100007626418086


Verification: Search the firm on the National Lawyer Credit Information Publicity System (credit.acla.org.cn) by firm name, practice license number, or Unified Social Credit Code


About the Author

Lixiaohua is a partner at Shanghai Lixiaohua Lawfirm, License No.

13101199310434143

Email: lxh@lxh-lawfirm.com

Tel:+86 21 63858668

Mobile:+86-15201864468